Skip to content
← Back to feed
Peter Welch (D-VT)
Peter Welch
Democrat·Vermont

Welch Presses Judicial Nominee on Derogatory Remarks Calling First Responders Injured by Corporate Negligence “Lottery” Winners

About About Peter Committee Assignments My Work (so far) Combating Trump’s Illegal Agenda Issues News Press Releases Press Kit Services Newsletter Sign-Up Help with a Federal Agency Academy Nominations Congressionally Directed Spending Requests Flag Requests Flooding Resources Internships Resources Resources for Immigrants Scheduling Requests Visiting DC Women’s Economic Opportunity Conference Contact Email Peter Press Release Welch Presses Judicial Nominee on Derogatory Remarks Calling First Responders Injured by Corporate Negligence “Lottery” Winners Nov 20, 2026 WASHINGTON, D.C . — U.S. Senator Peter Welch (D-Vt.), a member of the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Antitrust , Competition Policy , and Consumer Rights , this week pressed Arkansas Supreme Court Justice James Hiland , nominee to be United States Circuit Judge for the Eighth Circuit , for answers about his remarks demeaning first responders who suffered debilitating injuries as a result of corporate negligence as “lottery” winners in the case of Old Dominion Freight Line, Inc. v. McMillion . “I mean, this is pretty astonishing: This company that had a billion dollars in profit did not find it necessary to give a heads-up to first responders, who are among the best people in all of our communities. In Arkansas and in Vermont, those folks show up. And to deny them the heads-up that they’re going to walk into a place where they’re breathing and it’s going to cause permanent damage is really concerning to me. So, the judicial philosophy question here is what’s at the heart of my concern with you having this lifetime appointment,” said Senator Welch . “So, I’d just like you to explain how you square the—I think—derogatory language that you used towards the plaintiffs: ‘Powerball winners,’ when they had these very severe injuries that were all avoidable by a simple heads-up by an incredibly wealthy and successful corporation.” Watch the Senator’s full remarks below and on his YouTube channel : Senator Welch speaks at Senate Judiciary Committee hearing In 2026, Hiland dissented from the majority decision in Old Dominion Freight Line, Inc. v. McMillion , which considered a jury verdict awarded to six first responders who assisted with an accident involving a tractor-trailer carrying formic acid. The first responders alleged that Old Dominion negligently failed to inform them of the presence of hazardous material when they arrived on scene and complained of ongoing health issues due to the exposure, including breathing issues. After a trial, a jury found Old Dominion liable and awarded the first responders $75 million in compensatory damages for pain and suffering. The appellate court affirmed the jury’s finding regarding Old Dominion’s liability but ordered a new trial on damages; the Arkansas Supreme Court then vacated that opinion and affirmed the judgment. In Hiland’s dissent, he argued that the $75 million verdict was “excessive” and wrote: “The law does not permit juries to convert transitory or moderate injuries into generational wealth…[the judgment] transforms our civil justice system into something far more arbitrary—an institutionalized lottery, dispensing windfalls.” Read key excerpts from Senator Welch’s exchange with Justice James Hiland, nominee to be United States Circuit Judge for the Eighth Circuit: Sen. Welch: One of the rights that injured people have is the tort system. They can present their case to a jury, the jury—as you know—makes a determination: A, is there liability; B, what should be the damages. I understand there was a case involving Old Dominion where first responders who showed up got toxic injuries. There was a tractor-trailer that carried formic acid, and that’s an apparently very extremely dangerous substance. And the individuals who were the first responders got health problems, according to the majority opinion. They suffered reactive airway dysfunction—a very brutal injury, it’s like you’re breathing through a straw. The jury considered all the evidence, found Old Dominion liable, because it knew that this formic acid was there, but did not give a heads-up to the first responders. A simple heads-up to allow them to protect themselves. In your dissent, you said that, “the law does not permit juries to convert transitory or moderate injuries into generational wealth.” First of all, how is it that you describe these injuries as “transient or moderate” when the jury found that they were quite extreme? Justice Hiland: Senator, I’m in a tough position on—first of all, you’re taking the position that my friends on the majority took, so I understand. That case just went down. I don’t think the mandate has been issued in that case. There could be procedural opportunities for a re-hearing and some other things. Senator, respectfully, I would just hate to comment on that knowing that it could be coming back to the court. If the mandate had gone down, I’d be happy to talk about my position on that. Sen. Welch: Here’s what doe

Source: https://www.welch.senate.gov/welch-presses-judicial-nominee-on-derogatory-remarks-calling-first-responders-injured-by-corporate-negligence-lottery-winners
Captured:
Last seen live:
Record ID: 45adc39d-ec9e-4fe8-a88b-b7394b2733ee

Issued within 24 hours

Other senators' releases published in the day before or after this one.