Hawley Chairs First Congressional Hearing on Roblox, Demands Accountability for Child Exploitation and Forced Arbitration
WASHINGTON — Yesterday, U.S. Senator Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) chaired a Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism hearing to expose child sexual abuse connected to the kid’s gaming platform Roblox, as well as Roblox’s practice of trying to force victims into arbitration. The hearing was an extension of Senators Hawley and Dick Durbin (D-Ill.)’s investigation into Roblox, calling attention to the explicit content and child sexual exploitation connected to the platform. Just this week, the bipartisan pair introduced legislation to end forced arbitration for victims of online exploitation and to empower survivors from platforms like Roblox. Survivors offered powerful testimony at the hearing. Roblox CEO David Baszucki declined Senator Hawley’s invitation to testify at the hearing. Senator Hawley began , “We’re here today to discuss a question that I know from personal experience weighs on the mind of every parent in America, which is, ‘Are my children safe online?’ And the answer is, if your children are on Roblox, and millions of American children are every single day, they are not safe at all. Roblox is one of the most popular gaming platforms in the world, and if your children are on Roblox, they are being exposed, in all likelihood, to sexual predators, to sexually obscene materials, to sexually exploitative content, left, right, and center.” He continued , “The company is worth 33 billion dollars. The company’s CEO is worth 3.3 billion dollars on his own. And the sad fact of the matter is, is that much of that money and many of those profits have come from exposing children, and I do mean children, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 years old, to sexually obscene material. And the worst part of it is, is that after Roblox does this, and they know what’s going on on their platform, after they do it, they force these same child victims into arbitration, which is a fancy way of saying they slam the courthouse door shut in their faces. We’re talking about children now. Child victims of sexual exploitation online are denied their day in court by the very company that has exposed them to the content to begin with. Why? For money. It’s always the same answer. It’s for money.” Hawley then took a moment to recognize the parents of victims and survivors who were present in the room. “I want to say thank you for being willing to come and take a stand. Thank you for risking the pain that comes with reliving what your children went through … Thank you for being willing to come and to risk your own sense of well-being to be here and to speak out about what happened to you. Thank you for being advocates for the truth.” “Nearly 75% of all American children between the ages of nine and 12 play Roblox regularly,” Senator Hawley stated . ” … Predators pose as minors on Roblox to gain the trust of children. They also extort children with Roblox’s digital currency called Robux. As a result, countless criminal cases have come out of Roblox. It’s absolutely sickening.” He asked Woody Doe, survivor and online safety advocate , “Thanks for your service to our country, and thank you for the service to your family that you’re now entering as a husband and father. Let me just ask you: You were 11 years old. You said when you first started playing on Roblox, and when you were exploited. Is that right?” Mr. Doe responded , “Yes, Mr. Senator.” “When you got onto Roblox, did you think it was a safe platform, and did you have any reason to think it wouldn’t be?” Hawley questioned . “There were no indications that this would have been something dangerous for a young man to get onto … It seemed just like a virtual playground, like it was to … code, to come up with my own little worlds, and so I was so involved in it,” Doe answered . The Senator queried , “If you’re willing to say something more about it, how did the abuse that you experienced as a very young boy affect you years down the line?” He stated, “It came in multiple ways, if I’m being honest. There was years of feeling inadequacy … I felt vulnerable. I felt abused, and so with that, that stemmed all the way up into my military career, where I missed out on my second daughter’s actual birthday because I’d been volunteering, deployment, attachment, everything I could possibly embellish myself into to distract myself from the damages that had happened to me as a child, the long-lasting effects.” “I just got to pause there and say to the CEO of Roblox who isn’t with us today: Is it really worth it? I mean, is the money really worth that? What you did to this man and this incredible guy who’s in front of us now, who’s turned his life around and is an incredible advocate, father, husband? But no amount of money justifies what you went through, Mr. Doe. No amount of profit can justify that, and no amount of profit can justify closing the courtroom door on you or hundreds, thousands. Who knows how many of other victims who deserve their day in court who are getting exactly the same treatment you’re getting right now from this company,” Senator Hawley asserted . “What’s your view of Roblox now?” “I see them as lazy. Being honest, they have so much money to dump into their safety programs and protecting children, and they just refuse. The fact that this thing has happened to me over 15 years ago, and I’m still hearing the cases happening very similar to myself. It just goes to show that they haven’t put really any effort into keeping our kids safe,” Doe said . Senator Hawley then addressed Michael Schlep, survivor and online safety advocate , “Based on your experience catching predators on Roblox, does Roblox ensure that predators can’t contact children on their platform?” Schlep answered , “It was unbelievably easy for child predators to reach out. You know, I was able to find games where child predators would message me on Roblox within seconds. They allowed games based off of the now defunct platform Omegle, which was sued out of existence for child exploitation, to rack up tens of millions of visits on the platform, and Roblox’s chief safety officer Matt Kaufman actually played these games according to his Roblox profile, and these games weren’t removed until a major public outcry happened. And it goes to show that Roblox is very aware of some of these hubs and hotspots on the platform, but weren’t taking action. So this goes far beyond just you know allowing them to exist.” “When you started exposing just how common predation is on the Roblox platform and how common contact with predators is with children, how did Roblox respond again? Did they thank you? Did they say thank you for bringing this to our attention? Did they work with you? And what was their response?” Hawley questioned . “Roblox’s response was to send me a legal threat,” Schlep responded . “Roblox, they said that I was causing more of a danger to their users than the predators that I caught, which are now convicted. One was just recently sentenced to five years in prison, and you know the the thing is too. After all that came out, Roblox actually went as far as to compare me to child predators for running decoy accounts on their platform.” Hawley declared , “The CEO of Roblox said, … ‘If you’re not comfortable, then don’t let your kids be on Roblox.’ And you know, maybe that is actually a really good piece of advice … Roblox lies to parents all the time about how their how their their platform is safe. They tell parents it’s safe. They tell parents that there’s these safety features, and then when there’s a problem with kids … they turn around and they blame you. They say, well, ‘It’s your fault. You should have done it. You should have known. You should have been there. We’re doing our part, and it’s really your fault.’ When the truth is just the reverse. You’re doing your part, and they’re making the money. You’re doing your part, and they’re exploiting your kids, and it’s time to put a stop to it here.” He continued , “When Roblox says that they’ve implemented these safety features, they’re lying to you. Essentially, it’s all smoke and mirrors, it’s games, it’s window dressing, because they want their revenue stream to continue, and their revenue stream depends on kids who are my children’s age … Their whole business model depends on those kind of kids being on that platform all the time, which means it depends on lying to us parents about it and making sure we really can’t control anything that goes on the platform.” Senator Hawley then turned to Myriam Gilles, a law professor at Northwestern Pritzker School of Law , “Could you just underscore again why it’s so important that these cases happen in public, that they go into a real courtroom that that where there’s a jury right that that jury right is accessible. Tell us again why this is so viable.” “The short answer, Senator, is that courts produce a public record, and arbitration is designed to do the exact opposite. Right? It’s designed, as you’ve said, to muzzle, to to make everything as secret as possible, and public accountability produces reform,” Professor Gilles answered . “One of the terms and conditions is this: it’s a limitation of liability, and it says when you click that little box, you agree to that forced arbitration, no matter what your age is, and you also agree that any suit, any claim, any damages against Roblox or its affiliated parties for all claims will be limited to $1,000 total,” Hawley asserted . “They are currently worth $33 billion. The founder and CEO alone is worth $3.3 billion. Is 1000 bucks going to change anybody’s behavior?” Gilles said , “Absolutely not.” “What they’re really trying to do is they’re trying to avoid the moral responsibility for what they’re doing on their platform, and they don’t want any moral limits enforced on them. They want to say, ‘We’ll exploit your kids and take everything we can from them … there won’t be a thing you can do about it.’ And you know what? What we’ve said as a country over and over and over again is, we believe in markets and we believe in competition, but there are moral limits that we as a country impose on businesses and everybody else, and one of them is that you can’t exploit children,” he expressed . “… And the idea that we would allow this company to sexually exploit children or expose them to such in order to make money is just fundamentally un-American. It’s not who we are, and they know that, and they’re trying to get around our system of justice. And what I’m saying today is, what I hear everybody on this dais saying is, ‘It’s time to put a stop to that. It’s time to get back to some basic principles of right and wrong, and make the company follow up like everybody else in America does.'” Senator Hawley concluded , “I want to say to Roblox: You chose not to come here today, but you know what you’re doing is wrong, and we call on you today to admit your wrongdoing and to stop it. You can change your behavior, and you should. You should implement real safety regulations and restrictions like we talked about today. But you should also voluntarily end forced arbitration. I just say to CEO of Roblox, if you truly believe that your platform is the safest place on the internet for anybody. Prove it. End forced arbitration. You can announce it right now. Do it today. Today, announce that you will allow any victim who has been harmed on your platform to have their day in court because you have nothing to hide. I challenge you to do it. And in the meantime, I will not rest until this body marks up and passes a bill ending forced arbitration for victims of sexual exploitation and other exploitation online.” Watch the full hearing here . Read Senator Hawley’s bill empowering Roblox survivors here.
3ffdbde7-dd76-458e-9075-a10222776dcfIssued within 24 hours
Other senators' releases published in the day before or after this one.